The Base is going crazy. Conservative Brahmins, Talk-Radio Icons, Right Wing Bloggers, Callers, Readers and Writers are hopping and quivering with indignation. They're threatening to stay home on election day and let the Republicans get the beating they deserve.
Fuses are blowing, heads are exploding, nervous ticks are prevalent.
Peggy Noonan, in today's Opinion Journal suggests that there is a "disconnect" between the Administration and the Base. She wonders if, rather than the Base finding it doesn't much like George W. Bush, it is the President who finds he doesn't much like his Base. She muses that great power isolates the powerful and creates un-examined certainty.
I suppose that living in the rarified world of POTUS for years could have that effect. And it is certainly true that nearly everybody who cheered and supported this President on the Islamic War is feeling betrayed, surprised and angry at him over Immigration. The response is outrage and confusion, persistent and growing.
I'm pissed too. But I'm not perplexed, which seems to be the predominant emotion of people on all sides of the issue.
The Political Pragmatist can't understand how Bush could watch his numbers reach the bottom of the Marianas Trench and not leap on the popular side of this surfboard with both feet and ride the wave back to glory. They are bemused and perplexed.
The Principled Conservative can't understand how he can be so disengaged from an issue they see as critical to the defense of our culture, our homeland and our lives. They are furious and perplexed.
They've all missed the boat. (I am fond of my continuing Ocean Metaphor)
Since President Bush was elected, one of the things that we have loved about him is that he says what he means, and he does what he says. We respected and cheered him as he slogged on in the Islamic War, in the face of the combined fury of the gaseous MSM, the sissified churches, the hysterical Left, the corrupt and cowardly "world community", and traitors entrenched inside federal bureaucracies, all battling endlessly to undermine his support, his will, his confidence and his courage.
We said, proudly, "Look, here is a man who does not put his finger in the wind and follow the current trends. This is a man who leads, and who will, against all opposition, do what he thinks is right.
Hello!
When did he stop being that person? Well, never. It doesn't seem to have occured to all these perplexed and disoriented critics that he has not changed at all. He is doing, in the face of OUR opposition, just what he did in the face of THEIR oppositon: Precisely, and stubbornly what he thinks is right.
Please, don't misunderstand. I could not disagree with him more on the issue of ILLEGAL IMMIGRATION. I think his position is untenable, dangerous, misguided and suicidal. But, I have no doubt that he believes it's correct and righteous, and will go down with the ship in the face of a general Republican mutiny. He will not be intimidated by members of the Base any more than he was intimidated by members of Al Qaeda.
I think it's as simple as that. I think George W. Bush is a man who sticks to his principles whether its hard or easy, whether he loses friends or makes them, whether it's profitable or not, whether he looks good or looks bad. And for that I hold him in the highest esteem. It's a rare enough quality in the real world; it's damn near extinct in Washington.
That being said, I think his compassion is compromising his conservatism beyond recognition. He cannot be trusted at the helm in the Immigration Wars.
(I'm not mentioning shooting any of the bastards in a post about the President. The secret service is so very touchy about that)
The Gunslinger
Joebama American citizens 2024 print
10 months ago
A lefty viewpoint -
ReplyDeleteI've always thought Bush was dangerously incompetent, because he reminded me of incompetent managers I used to work for. I think the problem most Americans are having with Bush these days is not that he's lost touch with his base by straying from conservative values, but that people have caught on to both his general incompetence, and also how out of touch he is on a wide range of issues. My father in Ohio is a typical example. He used to love Bush, and voted for him both times, but now he just cracks jokes about Bush's lack of intelligence, and wonders why Bush keeps saying the economy is great when the Ohio economy is in the dumps. (BTW-Ohio government is totally dominated by Republicans for years, the way California was dominated by Democrats a few years ago.)
Bush is doing for conservative Republicans what Carter did for liberal Democrats. People are fed-up with Bush the way they got fed-up with Carter. Carter convinced people we had gone too far to the left, and Bush has convinced people we have gone too far to the right.
My problem isn't with conservative ideas. I think both conservatives and liberals have good and bad ideas. But I do have a certain contempt for ideologues of any stripe, because they lose touch with reality. Just by definition, the more ideological one is, the less removed from the real world they are. I think the conservative movement has become far too ideological, and too far removed from reality. When one party and ideology gets too strong, they invariably blow it.
When Democrats had total control in Sacramento a few years ago, they made a huge mess, and I think it was good that Arnold replaced Gray Davis. Arnold became a check on the excesses of the left. The far-right in Washington has also made a big mess. Americans are pressuring Washington to head back toward the center, where people are realists and not ideologues. The compromises and trade-offs necessary to deal with the real world can be pretty messy, and the current debate on illegal immigration reflects that. I don't like much of what I'm hearing proposed, and it's often because I don't think Bush and Congress are tough enough on illegals and the employers who hire them. The proposal about the fence is a farce. If you're going to build a fence, build it across the whole 2000-mile border, not just a few hundred miles. But I think both the far-right "throw 'em all out," and the far-left "give 'em amnesty" are wholly unrealistic. If the conservative base, which has been used to getting its own way, thinks that compromises are a sign of weakness and get angry, I'm not sympathetic. The conservative base never seemed too concerned if they made anyone else angry.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete(Well, I did it till I got it right. 4th time’s a charm. I had a hell of a time formatting this comment! Hint: Don’t use TextEdit to compose and copy!)
ReplyDeleteFinally... The GunsIinger replies:
I agree with everything Steve says. Well, except:
Bush is incompetent and unintelligent--
(They said it about Jefferson, Lincoln, Truman, Kennedy, Reagan…)
Bush is a Conservative—
(Education Bill? Prescription Drug Bill? Immigration? Federal Spending? Tariffs? We Conservatives beg to differ!)
Bush is an ideologue—
(I wish; see above))
The economy is bad—
(Every indicator says it’s good and has been for some time; this doesn’t mean there aren’t pockets in the country that are having problems.)
California is no longer run by Democrats—
(We have a legislature packed with the usual moon-howling collection of Left-Coast, Red-Diaper-Baby Socialist Democrat politicians who block every policy, program and reform of a RINO governor. This does not signal a power shift in the California Capitol.)
Democrats have good ideas—
(Any good ideas they’ve had in the last 50 years, have been conservative ones: welfare reform, tax cuts and strong national security in the days of yore. Were there others?)
Conservatives are too ideological—
(As opposed to Pelosi, Kennedy, Leahy, Reid, McKinny, Sharpton and Howard Dean, who famously claimed, “I hate Republicans and everything they stand for!” ???)
The Federal Government is run by the Far-Right—
(Iraq would be OVER! All illegals would already be DEPORTED!)
Americans feel we've gone too far to the right—
(Well, maybe Americans who live in San Francisco, Berkeley, Santa Cruz…and Pacifica*)
The Conservative base is used to getting their own way—
(Like abortion? school prayer? vouchers? 10 Commandments? the pledge? gay marriage? pornography? guns? the United Nations? oil drilling? nuclear power? smaller government? activist judges? Social Security? spending cuts? prescription drug entitlements? border security? "Merry Christmas"?...)
OK, so I agree with him on three things:
Bush and Congress are not tough enough on illegals—
(The House is doing just fine. It’s Old Mr. Compassionate and the House of Lords that are the problem.)
The proposal to build a partial fence is a farce—
(And, let me add, 6,000 National Guard is spit in a bucket.)
The Conservative base never seems too concerned if they make anyone else angry—
(Only a Liberal could think this is a BAD thing!)
So, old Steve and I don't exactly see eye to eye, but I'm glad he stopped by.
TG
*Steve lives in the same city I do. Some of us call it "Berkeley West". It is not a compliment.